Bought this to go with my new psp, took it out the box....its like cardboard with leather in the outside! psp fits very tightly have to pull psp quite hard to get it out. Then you try to put in a UMD into one of the slots (again you have to force it in) assuming you get it in...try to close the case...you cant because the magnetic catch doesnt connect with the other side so it stays open. Terrible case alround wouldnt give it house room! Dont know what the other case is like because it may be softer. Steer well clear if i were you.:-(